Digital Health

Blockchain in Healthcare: Real Uses or Just Hype?

Published 5 min read Acuitas Health Analytics

Blockchain in Healthcare: Real Uses or Just Hype?

Blockchain is a shared digital record that many parties can add to but no one can secretly change. It became famous through cryptocurrencies. In health care, it has been proposed for medical records, drug supply chains, consent, insurance claims and research data. The question is how much of this has moved beyond pilots.

What the evidence says

A 2023 systematic review of blockchain in the health care supply chain found 28 studies that met its criteria [1]. Of these, 54% were simulations, 43% were theoretical, and only one was a real case study [1]. The authors described interest in the topic as significant but immature, without effective real-life applications [1].

Blockchain health supply chain studies by type (%)0%14%27%41%54%Simulation studies54%Theoretical studies43%
Source: systematic review, Applied Sciences 2023 [1]. Only 1 of 28 was a real case study.

Drug supply chains

Counterfeit and diverted drugs are a real problem. In the US, the Drug Supply Chain Security Act (DSCSA) requires interoperable, electronic tracing of prescription drugs at the package level [2]. Its enhanced requirements started on 27 November 2023, with an FDA stabilisation period to 27 November 2024 [2]. Manufacturers, wholesalers and pharmacies must exchange data that identify each package.

The FDA ran pilot projects to test ways to meet these rules. One, MediLedger, tested a blockchain-based approach [3]. Blockchain is one possible tool, but traditional databases can also meet the requirements. The choice depends on cost, speed and how many partners need to share data.

Proposed uses

  • Drug tracing: recording each change of ownership of a drug package.
  • Consent: tracking who agreed to share data, and for what.
  • Credentials: verifying doctors' and nurses' licences across employers.
  • Clinical trials: time-stamping protocols and results to prevent changes.
  • Claims: sharing claims data between payers and providers.

Why adoption is slow

  • Most problems can be solved with ordinary databases at lower cost.
  • Blockchain needs many partners to agree on rules and governance.
  • Health privacy laws can clash with records that cannot be deleted.
  • Speed and energy use can be issues for some designs.
  • Data put into a blockchain are only as good as the data entered.

Security still matters

Blockchain does not make a whole system secure. HHS reports that hacking accounted for 79% of large health data breaches in 2023 [4]. Attackers usually target weak passwords, unpatched systems and people, not the database itself. Good basic security matters more than the type of database.

Key numbers at a glance

  • 28 studies in a 2023 review; only 1 real case study.
  • 54% simulation, 43% theoretical.
  • US DSCSA enhanced tracing began 27 November 2023.
  • Hacking: 79% of large US health breaches in 2023.

Questions before a blockchain project

  • What problem does it solve that a normal database cannot?
  • Who are the partners, and who runs the network?
  • How will privacy laws be met?
  • What happens if a partner leaves?

Go deeper

Want the full picture? Our report covers market size, growth, segments, countries and the key companies. Read the report or get a free sample.

Medical records on a blockchain?

An early idea was to store medical records on a blockchain. In practice, records are too large and too sensitive. Most proposals now keep records in normal systems and use a blockchain only to log who accessed them, or to record consent. Even this requires agreement across many organisations.

Health privacy and "the right to be forgotten"

Some privacy laws give people the right to have data deleted or corrected. A blockchain is designed so entries cannot be changed. This creates a conflict if personal data are written directly onto the chain. Designs that store only codes or links, not personal data, try to avoid this.

Where pilots have focused

  • Tracing drug packages between manufacturers, wholesalers and pharmacies.
  • Checking the credentials of health workers who move between hospitals.
  • Recording consent for research data use.
  • Sharing data on claims between insurers and providers.

The 2023 review found that most supply chain studies used smart contracts, which are rules that run automatically on the blockchain [1]. 82% of included articles involved them [1].

A simple test

Experts often suggest a short test before using blockchain: Do many parties need to share and add to the same records? Do they not trust a single owner to run the system? Does the record need to be tamper-evident over time? If the answer to all three is yes, blockchain may help. If not, a well-run shared database is usually simpler, faster and cheaper.

Bottom line for buyers

Treat blockchain as one tool among many. Start from the problem, involve all partners early, and compare costs with simpler options. Pilots should have clear success measures and a plan for what happens if they succeed.

What this means

Blockchain in health care is mostly still in pilots and papers. Its best chance is where many organisations must share trusted records without one central owner, such as drug tracing. Elsewhere, simpler technology often does the job better.

Where to read more

All figures in this article come from public sources listed below. For more detail, start with the 2023 systematic review in Applied Sciences and the FDA's DSCSA pages. Each is free to read online. If anything here raises a question about your own health, take this article to your doctor or pharmacist and talk it through together. Buyers, investors and policy makers can also use these sources to check claims made in sales materials, and to compare products and programmes on the same public evidence. Asking for the original source behind any number is a simple habit that leads to better decisions.

Explore on Acuitas

Topics: Health IT and data · Digital health

Sources

  1. Blockchain for the healthcare supply chain: a systematic literature review (Applied Sciences, 2023)
  2. US FDA: Implementing DSCSA – stabilization period and expectations
  3. US FDA: MediLedger DSCSA pilot project report
  4. HHS Office for Civil Rights (Mar 2024): large breaches and ransomware

Banner image: Data center roof by Rsparks3, CC0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Topics: Health IT and data · Digital health

Back to Blog