OTC & Nutraceuticals

Men's Health Supplements: Beyond the Marketing

Published 5 min read Acuitas Health Analytics

Men's Health Supplements: Beyond the Marketing

Men's health supplements are sold for energy, muscle, testosterone, sexual performance, prostate health and hair. Many promise quick results. Some contain useful vitamins or minerals. But this category also has some of the weakest evidence and the most safety warnings of any supplement group.

Testosterone boosters

A study of popular "testosterone boosting" supplements looked at whether their ingredients had published evidence. Only 24.8% of the products had data showing an increase in testosterone. 18.3% had data showing no change, and 10.1% had data showing a decrease. For 61.5%, no data on testosterone could be found at all [1].

Evidence behind testosterone booster supplementsNo published data61.5%Data showing an increase24.8%Data showing no change18.3%Data showing a decrease10.1%
Source: Clemesha et al., World Journal of Men's Health 2020 [1]. Products could fall into more than one group.

Low testosterone is a real medical condition, but it should be diagnosed with blood tests and treated by a doctor. Symptoms like tiredness or low mood have many other causes, including poor sleep, depression and other illnesses.

Hidden drugs in sexual enhancement products

A study of US FDA warnings from 2007 to 2016 found 776 supplements containing hidden drug ingredients [2]. Most were sold for sexual enhancement (45.5%), weight loss (40.9%) or muscle building (11.9%) [2]. Among the tainted sexual enhancement products, the most common hidden drug was sildenafil, the active ingredient in Viagra, found in 47% of them [2].

Tainted supplements by marketed use, 2007-20160%11%23%34%46%Sexual enhancement45.5%Weight loss40.9%Muscle building11.9%
Source: Tucker et al., JAMA Network Open 2018 [2].

Hidden drugs are dangerous because people do not know they are taking them. Sildenafil can cause a dangerous drop in blood pressure when combined with nitrate heart medicines. The FDA keeps a public list of tainted products [5].

Prostate supplements

Saw palmetto is one of the most popular herbs sold for an enlarged prostate. NCCIH says a 2023 review of 27 studies found that saw palmetto alone gives little or no benefit for prostate symptoms [3]. NCCIH also notes that the evidence does not support using saw palmetto for any health condition [4].

Urinary symptoms can also be a sign of other conditions, so men should see a doctor rather than self-treat.

Muscle and energy products

  • Protein powders: useful if diet is short of protein, but most men already eat enough.
  • Creatine: good evidence for strength training performance.
  • "Pre-workout" blends: often high in caffeine; check the dose.
  • Products claiming steroid-like effects: high risk of hidden ingredients.

What men often need instead

  • Regular blood pressure, blood sugar and cholesterol checks.
  • Talking to a doctor about prostate and bowel cancer screening at the right age.
  • Vitamin D or B12 testing if at risk of deficiency.
  • Help with sleep, stress, alcohol and smoking.

Warning signs on a label

  • Promises of results "in minutes" or "like a prescription drug".
  • Marketed as an alternative to an approved medicine.
  • Sold mainly online with no clear company address.
  • Claims to be "100% natural" with dramatic effects.

Key numbers at a glance

  • Only 24.8% of testosterone boosters had data showing they raise testosterone.
  • 776 tainted supplements in FDA warnings, 2007-2016.
  • 45.5% of those were sold for sexual enhancement.
  • Saw palmetto: little or no benefit in a review of 27 studies.

Go deeper

Want the full picture? Our report covers market size, growth, segments, countries and the key companies. Read the report or get a free sample.

Common myths

  • "Natural products cannot hurt you." Hidden drugs and herb-drug interactions can cause real harm [2].
  • "Feeling tired means low testosterone." Tiredness has many causes; only a blood test can show low testosterone.
  • "Prostate supplements prevent cancer." No supplement has been shown to prevent prostate cancer.

Reading the label

  • Check the exact ingredient and dose, not just the brand name.
  • Look for an independent quality seal, such as USP or NSF.
  • Be wary of words like "clinically proven" without a named study.
  • Check for a batch number and expiry date.
  • Avoid "proprietary blends" that hide how much of each ingredient is inside.

Questions to ask your doctor

  • Do my symptoms need a blood test or a check-up first?
  • Could this product interact with my heart or blood pressure medicines?
  • Which health checks should I have at my age?
  • Is there a proven treatment for what I am trying to fix?

In short

Be very careful with products promising sexual or hormone effects. See a doctor for symptoms, and choose tested brands for basic vitamins and minerals.

What this means

Men's supplements are a crowded market with uneven evidence and real safety risks. Checking with a doctor, getting the right tests and choosing quality-tested products protects both health and money.

Where to read more

All figures in this article come from public sources listed below. For more detail, start with the NCCIH men's health page and the FDA list of tainted supplements. Each is free to read online. If anything here raises a question about your own health, take this article to your doctor or pharmacist and talk it through together. Buyers, investors and policy makers can also use these sources to check claims in sales materials and compare options on the same public evidence. Where public sources disagree or update their figures, we note the year of each number so readers can see how the picture changes over time.

Explore on Acuitas

Topics: Men's health · Nutrition

Sources

  1. Clemesha CG et al. "Testosterone boosting" supplements composition and claims are not supported by the academic literature (World Journal of Men's Health, 2020)
  2. Tucker J et al. Unapproved pharmaceutical ingredients included in dietary supplements associated with US FDA warnings (JAMA Network Open, 2018)
  3. NCCIH: Saw palmetto, usefulness and safety
  4. NCCIH: Men's health
  5. US FDA: Tainted products marketed as dietary supplements

Banner image: Jogging at the Arch (bb1d0e33-59b2-4608-ab0d-b411de93becd) by NPS Photo, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Topics: Men's health · Nutrition

Back to Blog